Best Pet Insurance for Multiple Pets of 2024 (2024)

Do you have more than one pet and want pet insurance for all of them? Luckily, some of the best pet insurance companies offer multi-pet perks, such as discounts on your premiums.

We reviewed numerous insurers to find the ones that offer the best benefits for your pack. Here’s the lineup of the best pet insurance for multiple pets.

Our Top Picks for the Best Pet Insurance for Multiple Pets

• MetLife: Best Overall for Multiple Pets
• Spot: Best Value for Multiple Pets
• Embrace: Best for Customizable Options
• ASPCA: Best Comprehensive Multi-Pet Plan
• Nationwide: Best for Multiple Exotic Pets

Best Pet Insurance for Multiple Pets Reviews

Sample quotes below are based on monthly costs for accident and illness policies with a $500 deductible, 80% reimbursement rate and $5,000 annual limit. The pets are medium mixed-breed dogs and domestic shorthair cats living in North Carolina.

We chose MetLife as the best pet insurance for multiple pets overall because you can save a significant amount of money by getting a family plan instead of individual plans for each pet.

With a family plan, all insured pets will have one premium with a shared deductible and coverage. And you can insure cats and dogs on the same policy. If you’d rather be able to customize your coverage for each pet, you can buy individual plans instead and receive a multi-pet discount.

Spot pet insurance was the most affordable option we found when retrieving sample quotes. It was cheaper for both domestic shorthair cats and mixed-breed dogs, and it offers affordable wellness coverage you can add to your policy to get reimbursed for routine care, such as vaccines, annual checkups and dental cleanings. However, quotes for other breeds were more expensive, so your price may vary.

Spot’s multi-pet discount is generous at 10% for each additional pet you insure. Plus, you can save even more money if you pay for the policy upfront for the year rather than monthly.

Embrace pet insurance is a great option that offers accident-and-illness and accident-only plans. It has various annual reimbursement limit options ranging from $5,000 to unlimited. Its deductibles range from $100 to $1,000.

Our sample quotes for Embrace were more expensive than those of some other companies on this list, but you may qualify for other discounts, such as military or healthy pet discounts. Embrace’s multi-pet discount is the highest that most companies offer, at 10%.

ASPCA earned a spot on our list of the best companies for multiple pets because it offers affordable, comprehensive plans. Insuring more than one pet with ASPCA gets you a 10% discount on all additional pets. The sample quotes we received were more affordable than the rates many other companies offered.

Nationwide is our top pick for exotic pet parents. Since the needs of each pet differ, Nationwide offers customized coverage for pet care based on the type of pet you have. It has three categories: birds, small mammals, and reptiles and amphibians.

While the multi-pet discount is only 5% if you have two to three pets, the discount increases to 10% if you insure four or more. Nationwide may not be the best option if you have multiple dogs because the price was higher than some other companies’ prices. However, the quotes for cats were more affordable.

Other Companies We Considered

The following list contains other companies that may be worth considering for multi-pet insurance:

• Lemonade: 5% multi-pet discount
• Figo: 5% multi-pet discount on each pet’s policy
• Prudent Pet: 10% multi-pet discount on each pet’s policy
• Pumpkin: 10% multi-pet discount for each additional pet you enroll

Pet Insurance for Multiple Pets Guide

Having multiple pets is extremely rewarding but also means extra vet bills. Luckily, pet insurance can help protect you financially from unexpected veterinary treatment for all of your furry friends.

Here’s more information about insuring multiple pets.

How does pet insurance for multiple pets work?

Multi-pet insurance works similarly to insurance for one pet. However, you can insure multiple pets in a few different ways.

• Separate policies for each pet: Most companies require you to get separate policies for each pet. If you buy them all from the same company, you can usually manage them under the same account. However, they will have separate premiums, deductibles and coverage limits. An upside is that you can customize your coverage for each pet. Plus, many companies offer multi-pet discounts.

• Multiple pets on one policy: Some companies allow you to insure multiple pets on the same policy. This would mean you’d have one premium and one deductible for all your pets. A downside to this is that you may not be able to customize your coverage for each pet; they will likely all have the same coverage.

What does pet insurance for multiple pets cover?

Pet insurance for multiple pets covers treatment for accidents and illnesses for all insured pets. Coverage works the same as a policy that covers one pet. You can choose from accident-only plans or accident and illness plans. You may also be able to add a wellness rider for each pet.

Here are some examples of what accident and illness pet insurance covers:

• Injuries
• Illnesses
• Emergency treatment
• Dental emergencies
• X-rays and other imaging
• Hospitalization
• Cancer
• Allergies
• Prescription medication

Can the insurance policy be customized for each pet?

Pet insurance companies typically allow you to customize your coverage for each pet you insure. For example, you may want accident and illness coverage for one dog but accident-only coverage for your other dog.

The only time you wouldn’t be able to customize each pet’s coverage is if you insure them all on one policy. In that case, they’ll all have the same coverage, premium, deductible and limits.

How much is a pet insurance policy for multiple pets

The average cost of pet insurance for multiple pets is around $36 to $70 for two dogs and around $19 to $48 for two cats. Pet insurance costs can vary based on the following factors:

• Type of pets you insure (cats are usually cheaper)
• Location
• Pet breeds and ages
• Coverage options
• Annual coverage limits
• Annual deductible
• Reimbursement rate
• Eligible discounts
• Insurance provider

The table below includes sample monthly premiums for multiple pets.

How do you compare pet insurance for multiple pets?

Before you settle on a pet insurance company, it’s important to compare your options to find the best deal. Consider the following factors when buying pet insurance for multiple pets:

• Policy structure: Determine if the company lets you buy one policy for all your pets or requires separate policies.

• Multi-pet discount: Multi-pet discounts typically range from 5% to 10% off each policy. Some companies apply the discount to all policies, while others only apply it to the additional pets you add.

• Claim process: You may take your pets to the vet at the same time but likely need to submit claims for each pet separately. Inquire about each company’s claim process and look for simple and easy ones.

• Customization: All pets have different needs. Customization may be important if you want more coverage for one of your pets.

• Coverage options: Pet insurance coverage can differ by company, so review each company’s list of covered services and policy options.

• Waiting period: A pet insurance waiting period is the time you have to wait after you purchase a policy until your coverage becomes effective. These can vary by company, but shorter waiting periods are better.

• Exclusions: All pet insurance companies have exclusions (like pre-existing conditions). Before buying a policy, ensure you know what pet insurance won’t cover so there are no surprises when it comes time to file a claim.

• Wellness plan options: Many insurers offer wellness plans you can add to your policy to get coverage for routine and preventative veterinary care. See what each company’s wellness plan add-on covers and costs — they vary significantly by company.

• Cost: Cost is one of the most important factors when shopping for a multi-pet policy. Get quotes from multiple companies and compare the costs and coverage to find the best deal.

Is a multi-pet insurance policy worth it?

A multiple-pet insurance policy may be worth it for you so all your pets can be covered. While the cost adds up with the more pets you insure, multi-pet discounts typically range from around 5% to 10% off.

When deciding if it’s worth it, consider the cost of a policy, its benefits and your pet’s needs.

More About Pet Insurance

• How to Make a Pet Insurance Claim
• Pet Insurance For Pre-existing Conditions
• Does Pet Insurance Cover Surgery?
• 7 Smart Ways to Save Money on Your Pets
• Cats vs. Dogs: Things to Consider in Your Pet Insurance Cost

How We Chose the Best Pet Insurance for Multiple Pets

To determine our list of the best pet insurance companies for multiple pets, we considered the following factors:

• Multi-pet policy options: Your multi-pet insurance policy options can vary by company. Some allow you to insure them all on one policy, while others require you to get separate policies. We analyzed policy options from numerous companies to find favorable and affordable pet insurance for multiple pets.

• Multi-pet discounts and benefits: Not all pet insurance companies offer multi-pet discounts. We favored companies that offer the highest discounts for insuring multiple pets.

• General coverage: We considered the companies’ coverage options and exclusions to ensure they offer a good value.

• Customer experience: We favored companies with easy quoting and sign-up processes.

Summary of Money’s Best Pet Insurance for Multiple Pets

• MetLife: Best Overall for Multiple Pets
• Spot: Best Value for Multiple Pets
• Embrace: Best for Customizable Options
• ASPCA: Best Comprehensive Multi-Pet Plan
• Nationwide: Best for Multiple Exotic Pets